This year’s presidential race has generated more interest, expressions of concern, and questions from clients than any we can remember. Some want to know how the election impacts our investment views and how we might adjust our positioning in anticipation, while some have asked how we factor elections into our analysis and portfolio construction more generally.
First and foremost, we never try to bet on outcomes. What we do try to do, regardless of market or election cycle, is maintain an investment discipline that is long-term in focus, based on analyzing valuations and fundamentals, and that attempts to limit downside risk. Viewed through that lens, what are we watching, analyzing, and positioning for?
1. Market volatility
Along with sudden shocks (e.g., terrorist strikes), unexpected developments (such as the Brexit vote results), and lately, central bank actions, presidential elections can certainly drive short-term market swings. But the longer-term impact is a different story. The following chart from Ned Davis Research contains data on election cycles from 1900 through 2012. It shows that during presidential election years financial market swings have tended to be magnified in the final weeks of the campaign. This has been particularly true in years when the incumbent party lost. Once voting was over, markets have rallied going into year-end.
2. Economic fundamentals—long-term outlook
Over a full market cycle, returns are driven by fundamentals, not temporary shifts in investor sentiment, short-term momentum trading, flights to safety, or political rhetoric. While the U.S. economy could hardly be called robust, growth is positive, unemployment is down, and wages are up. Consumer spending is increasing, and confidence recently hit a 12-month high. None of these are likely to change overnight based on what happens in November. Yes, fiscal policy can impact all of them in the long-term, and there are important differences in the candidates’ policy stances, but presidents don’t get to decide these things in a vacuum. Without knowing which policy proposals will eventually be enacted, when, or how, making preemptive changes to portfolios is more likely to hurt than help.
3. Downside risk
It’s unclear how much markets are pricing in current polling data, but the election’s outcome could still turn out to be surprising. Even if market prices accurately reflect the results, how they would react over the short and longer terms is a different story. We are more focused on the impact of U.S. interest rates rising over the next several years. With the Federal Reserve and other central banks’ policies playing outsized roles in recent years—pushing stock prices higher and spurring bond yields to record lows—we see downside risks as they begin to pull back. We have already seen short-term spikes in yields push bond prices down and drive stock market swings in anticipation of rising interest rates. With the S&P 500 currently valued at a historically high earnings multiple (price-to-earnings ratio) that is not supported by strong corporate earnings trends, a rise in U.S. interest rates from their abnormally low levels is just one thing that could put downward pressure on prices.
Dealing with uncertainty
How do we deal with uncertainty? Whether election-driven or otherwise, we deal with it by not making sudden moves in or out of markets based on headlines. Instead, we develop and assess a range of scenarios, then construct diversified portfolios that are positioned to meet our clients’ longer-term goals, while minimizing the impact of temporary market falls.
While elections do matter, investing at reasonable valuations, balancing risk against potential reward, and not letting anxiety drive your decisions matter more.
Do you have more questions about the topics covered in this post? Call your Litman Gregory Investment Advisor or contact us here.
Actions to Take in Uncertain Times
In a volatile environment like the one we find ourselves in today, and experienced just two years ago in 2020, we recognize that some investors feel as though they should make changes in their portfolios—even if just to take action.
Research Update on Market Volatility
Given the renewed market downturn, fed by high uncertainty around inflation and the war in Ukraine, we want to share our most-current views and portfolio positioning with clients and followers of our research.
Commentary from Our CIO—First Quarter 2022
In this commentary, we highlight key developments in the global economy and financial markets. The biggest macro event was Russia’s brutal invasion of Ukraine. As is our job, our focus is on the economic and financial market impact of this event. Clearly, the human impact has been devastating and tragic, and our hearts and support are with the Ukrainian people.